Go Thistles! The finest names from old NYC soccer teams

Above: The New York Nationals and the New Bedford Whalers play the Polo Grounds, circa 1928 (Courtesy NYPL)

The announcement on Tuesday of a second Major League Soccer team for New York — sponsored by Manchester City FC and the New York Yankees — has sent me down a rabbit hole of soccer history, courtesy this excellent and exhaustive article on the subject by David Litterer.

The New York Football Club will join the New York Red Bulls on the soccer fields in 2015.  But when do they get a new name? NYCFC seems so, I don’t know, average.

New Yorkers have been playing soccer for almost 140 years with regional leagues forming in the 1880s.  By the early 1900s, newspapers were beginning to call it soccer (or “soccer” football, as in this article). Here are a few of the more interesting names of organized soccer teams from New York City over the many years:

New York Thistles — played from the early 1880s until 1906.  Among their colorfully named competition in those years were the Brooklyn Longfellows, the New York Caledonians, New York Nonpareils and the Williamsburg Shamrocks.

New York Hakoah — The original Hakoah (Hebrew for ‘strength’) played in New York during in the 1920s, derived from a Jewish Austrian sports club of the same name.  (It eventually derived many of its players from the Austrian team too.)  Several players inducted into the National Soccer Hall of Fame played for the Hakoah at one point.  There is presently a team by this name keeping up the tradition in New Jersey.

New York Americans — This patriotic team formed by Hungarian player Emo Schwarz entertained audiences during the Great Depression, along with the New York Brookhattan.  In the 1950s, they actually merged with another team to form a second incarnation of the New York Hakoah.

New York Skyliners — Playing all their games at Yankee Stadium, the New York Skyliners were a curious aberration that lasted only a single season (1967), giving New York two professional soccer teams (the other being the New York Generals).  Nobody on the team was from New York; they were simply the (briefly) rebranded Cerro team from Montevideo, Uruguay.  By the end of 1968, both the Generals and the Skyliners had folded.

New York Cosmos — Soccer made a serious push to rival baseball and football in the United States in the 1970s, and New York’s entrant into this new spotlight were the Cosmos, who played from 1971 to 1984.  In late 1970s, at the height of their popularity, they were packing 40,000 people per game into Giants Stadium, thanks in part to their star player Pelé (pictured above).  Sadly, the excitement for soccer waned in the 1980s. The North American Soccer League folded, as did the Cosmos.

But everything is new again. A new of the NASL started up again in 2011, as is a new edition of the New York Cosmos, starting this seas.  So, for now, this name is off-limits.

There’s also a host of one-shot names that cropped up in old “soccer” football records between 1860 and 1880s.  From that list, I’d like to offer up the following names —  New York Married & Singles, New York Dauntless, New York Gentlemen, New York Pilgrims and the New York Westside Rovers.

Of course, if there is a new name, it will probably be a product of some sort. But at least make it a New York-based product please! The New York Snapples? The New York Katzs’?  The New York Shake Shacks?

NOTE: If any New York soccer fans have any corrections to the information above, please send them along. Thanks!

2 replies on “Go Thistles! The finest names from old NYC soccer teams”

A couple of footnotes:

The very first national championship for soccer in the US was between Brooklyn Celtic and Brooklyn Field Club in 1914.

Greek-American Atlas from Astoria won 4 times in the non-professional era.

Another one of the most successful teams from the pre-modern era was the Brooklyn Italians, with two national championships. And they still play at Floyd Bennett Field.

The professional team in NJ has never won anything. 🙂

It’s important to note that this team will be called New York *CITY* FC. Nicknamed the Citizens? The owner also has another team in England called Manchester City and there will probably be some tie-in between the two.

Incidentally, their fan group is called the Borough Boys. Evidently someone was already using the Bowery Boys moniker!

I’m a member of the Empire Supporters Club, one of the Red Bulls fan groups. Our group actually predates the team, as its earliest members supported the New York Centaurs in 1995, who played at old Downing Stadium on Randall’s Island, which was later demolished and re-built as the Icahn Stadium for track and field.

The Red Bulls were founding members of Major League Soccer in 1996, but from 1996-2005 they were known as the New York/New Jersey MetroStars, and later, simply MetroStars. They have played all of their home games in New Jersey at Giants Stadium or the shiny new Red Bull Arena, which opened in 2010. They were purchased by Red Bull GmbH in 2006 and re-branded with their present moniker. Red Bull did the same thing with clubs in Austria and Germany, essentially erasing the histories of two clubs, changing the team’s colors and names.

At home games the ESC sings, chants and claps for all 90 minutes. The majority of its members sing “Metro” in their lyrics instead of “Red Bulls.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *