The Knick Wartime New York

Knickerbocker Hospital: An inspiration for Cinemax’s The Knick

Photographed dated 1886, the institution was called Manhattan Hospital then, changing its name to J. Hood Wright Memorial Hospital, then to Knickerbocker Hospital in 1913 (Picture courtesy the Museum of the City of New York)

On Friday begins The Knick on Cinemax, a historical drama set in the turn-of-the-century Knickerbocker Hospital. . Last year, Tom wandered around the Broome Street set of The Knick. (Check out his pictures here.)  Are you checking this out live this Friday night (August 8, 10pm)?  Follow along with me on Twitter where I’ll try and keep up with historical tidbits about the era and the events that are depicted.

Although the hospital depicted in the show is technically fictional, there was a Knickerbocker Hospital in New York during this time period. It will be interesting to see if the show’s institution bears any resemblance to the real Knickerbocker:

Knickerbocker Hospital
Location: Covent Avenue and 131st Street
The hospital depicted in The Knick is much, much further downtown.  However, with the arrival of elevated trains and, later, the subway, some new immigrants would have settled in upper Manhattan to escape the crowded tenements. So the types of patients treated at these institutions would have been similar.

Purpose:  According to the 1914 Directory of Social and Health Agencies, “Gives free surgical and medical treatment to the worthy sick poor of New York City.  Incurable and contagious diseases and alcoholic, maternity and insane patients not admitted.  Emergency cases received at any hour.”
Statistics:  In 1914, they had 57 beds, 1,096 cases treated in a year
Funding: Care is free to “the worthy poor” and the hospital is supported by charitable contribution

History:  The hospital began its existence as the Manhattan Dispensary in 1862, located in upper Manhattan when it pretty much looked like this:  (Image courtesy the US National Library of Medicine)

The hospital treated injured Civil War soldiers.  It was founded by a Philadelphia railroad man named James Hood Wright who worked for banker J.P. Morgan.  

Mr. Wright died suddenly on November 12, 1894, collapsing at an elevated train station on Rector Street and never regained consciousness.  In honor of his contributions, the hospital was renamed the J. Hood Wright Memorial Hospital, although, from reading the news clipping below, it seems that was not a great idea.

The name change was facilitated by a lack of funding for the hospital.  In 1910, hospital executives blatantly proclaimed “the hospital was inadequate to serve the needs of the west side of Harlem.”

From a notice in the New York Sun, June 23, 1913:

“The J. Hood Wright Memorial Hospital, which was incorporated in 1868 as the Manhattan Dispensary, has got permission from Supreme Court Justice Page to change its name to the Knickerbocker Hospital.

The petition says that since Mr. Wright’s death the population of the district served by the hospital has increased greatly and the necessity of more funds for the hospital has increased proportionately.

The hospital managers and Mr. Wright’s heirs believe that the present name of the hospital leads to the belief that it is so liberally endowed it does not require outside assistance and for this reason, none have been forthcoming.  They say Mr. Wright desired outsiders to contribute.”

J. Hood Wright is memorialized in a public park just off the Manhattan approach to the George Washington Bridge. located on the land where Mr. Wright’s mansion once stood.

At right: A photo of the old Wright house. You can see the George Washington Bridge in the background. (Courtesy Museum of the City of New York)

The Knickerbocker’s neighborhood of Harlem became the heart of New York’s African-American culture, but hospital staffing did not reflect this change.

There were many reported incidents of black patients being poorly treated here during the 1920s and 30s.  According to author Nat Brandt, the wife of W.C. Handy “lay critically ill in an ambulance for more than an hour while officials of Knickerbocker Hospital discussed whether to admit her.” [source]

In May 1959, Billie Holiday was admitted here after collapsing in her apartment, but her liver and heart disease were so advanced that she was transferred to a hospital better suited for treatment. (She died a few weeks later.)

Knickerbocker Hospital remained open until the early 1970s when mounting debts almost forced it to close.  The state of New York took it over and renamed it Arthur C. Logan Memorial Hospital after a prominent black physician.  That hospital seemed to suffer from the same financial woes as the others and eventually closed for good in 1979.

I’m looking forward to doing more research New York’s medical institutions in the coming weeks, and I hope the show does it justice!

A scene from The Knick. There will be blood, I believe….

(Photograph courtesy Cinemax)

24 replies on “Knickerbocker Hospital: An inspiration for Cinemax’s The Knick”

I watched the first episode, it takes a lot to shock me, but holy hell my mouth was on the floor, excited to keep watching, nice to see shows rooted i actual history

As an OR nurse; I can say they’ve got great advisors on this. FABULOUS ! And that music! Incongruent in a modern Phillip Glass kinda sorta way, but it work!
Too bad I don’t get Cinemax but thanks for the promotion.

Wonder how we will look to health care givers one hundred years from now? I am reminded of the lines which were written for “Bones” in Star Trek IV, when the 20th Century surgeons were about to perform a craniotomy on Chekov to treat his subdural hematoma.

The medical field has always been very challenging. I cannot imagine the pressure without the advances of today. So far I’m hooked.

The technology woes of healthcare continue electricity or electronic medical records; the crooked health inspector or control of pharma, insurance and inconsistencies of CMS. comparisons can be made!

Being a RN the show does seem to have fantastic advisors on what treatments were available for the illnesses that plagued the time period. I am hooked!

I saw the show on HBO over the weekend and loved it. Sorry to say I do not have Cinemax. Great contribution on the history.


Examining the historical presence of the show after much researchfof the medical research done during the relevant time period to be spot on, the use of the name of the hospital in relevance to the city, brilliant, Soderbergh is so unique in tracing his projects, so many sociological story lines to follow, civil rights, women’s rights, patients rights, legal drug use (at that time), overall scientific technology and change in an internment amount of real life time. Touche to the writer, and all staff working on this incredible show, breathtaking

A good show, to which I look forward every week. I wish the lighting was a little better, though – I know it is redolent of the times, but as a TV viewer I could do with seeing what’s going on a little better!

just finished all the episodes of season one’s , The Knick-was fascinated by the surgical procedures and not so enthralled with all the cocaine injections. i hope the next season will not be mostly about how to use heroin.

Does anyone know why they changed the location of the Knickerbocker Hospital from 131st Street and Convent Avenue to the Lower East Side? I’m sure they could have found many interesting stories from Manhattanville. There were lots of different ethnic groups there, including many Irish – many members of my family died in The Knickerbocker (or J. Hood Wright) from various causes.

I was born in Knickerbocker Hospital in 1938 . I came from 124th St. which was at the time Jewish,German and Irish. After the Harlem riots during the war we moved uptown

I have just discovered this Hospital as one of my relatives died there in 1937 and only lived 9 minutes away from the place on Amsterdam ave. Its amazing to see Manhatten and how it looks and to think that my family were walking around the area in the 1930’s & 40’s.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *